For a limited time, get free shipping on any U.S. order!


The Motley's Second Annual

2015 Best In Shop

Our top 25 picks in men's skincare, shaving, haircare and
hair styling that are worth every single dollar.

Sweeten the deal: we've paired free gifts with many
of our favorite selections. They're limited, so
we suggest that you act quick!

Pick a category:
Cleansers and Moisturizers / Shaving / Treatments / Hair / Hand and Body


~ Best Cleansers and Moisturizers ~


A powerful, multi functional daily cleanser that utilizes the deep cleaning, exfoliating properties of kaolin clay, volcanic ash and glycolic acid to clear away dead skin cells and pore-clogging oil and grime. For deep cleaning, this cleanser can also be used as a purifying face mask when left to dry on skin. Recommended for combination and oily skin types. Fragrance and paraben free. Vegan formula.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase a full size Jack Black Deep Dive Glycolic Facial Cleanser and receive a complimentary Jack Black Double Duty Moisturizer deluxe sample!




There are moments in life when you need to freshen up in a hurry. These handy one-time wipes don’t just provide a little soothing relief—they also exfoliate, cleanse, tone, and hydrate when your usual grooming arsenal is miles away.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase the Ursa Major Essential Face Wipes and receive a travel size Ursa Major 4-in-1 Face Tonic!





Buckler's Daily Face Repair

A lightweight face lotion to repair and soothe sensitive, distressed skin. Recommended as a daily moisturizer for sensitive skin types, especially those prone to redness, or as a soothing salve for sunburned or irritated skin. A natural, vegan formula made with certified organic, fair trade ingredients.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase a Buckler's Daily Face Repair and receive a complimentary Buckler's Moisture Rich Bar Soap!





Evolution Man Moisture Protect SPF 20

A non-greasy, ultra-lightweight matte face moisturizer with sun protection. Moisturizes, soothes and protects skin from sun damage. Ultra-lightweight, greaseless and matte formula. Titanium dioxide provides SPF 20 UV protection. Contains antioxidants- green tea vitamins E and C.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase an Evolution Man Moisture Protect SPF 20 and receive a complimentary Evolution Man Lip Balm!



~ Best Shaving ~



Baxter of California Shave Tonic

A skin toner loaded with essential oils and vitamins to help you get the best shave possible and maintain healthy skin pre- and post- shave. Menthol, rosemary, eucalyptus, camphor and spearmint tone and revitalize skin.Aloe extract and vitamins A, D and E restore moisture and essential nutrients to the skin.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase a Baxter of California Shave Tonic and receive a complimentary Baxter of California Trial-Size Shave Duo!





Port Products Face Saving Shave Formula

A superior barrier formulated for the closest shave. This ultra concentrated cream includes coconut oil extracts that reduce surface tension and allow for a close shave. Willow bark extract and aloe vera provide anti-inflammatory properties that both soothe and hydrate skin. Developed because shaving shouldn't be a drag.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase a full size Port Products Face Saving Shave Formula and receive a complimentary travel size Port Products Balancing Daily Moisturizer!




This rich, creamy lathering shave cream utilizes macadamia nut oil, glycerin and soybean oil to create a triple layer of protection against razor burn, irritation, nicks and cuts. Macadamia nut oil and jojoba oil soften tough hairs and hydrate skin. Soybean oil and glycerin soften and protect skin. Organic edelweiss and plantago leaf extracts are antioxidants that fight environmental skin damage.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase a Jack Black Supreme Cream Triple Cushion Shave Lather and receive a complimentary Jack Black Double Duty Moisturizer deluxe sample!





Apivita After Shave Balm

A shave balm made with natural ingredients that soothes, freshens and hydrates skin post shave. Balsam, calendula, chamomile and sambucus extracts soothe skin. Birch extract tones and hydrates, and antiseptic propolis heals any nicks and cuts while protecting against infection and irritation. A blend of cedar, cardamom, lemon and clary sage freshens and rejuvenates the skin. Free of parabens, silicone, propylene glycol, alcohol and mineral oil.




An all natural, hydrating beard oil that softens and smooths facial hair while moisturizing the skin beneath with nourishing antioxidants. Argan and Grapeseed oils restore a healthy balance to unruly hair and dry, flaky skin without clogging pores.




Get the best shave possible with this German-made, custom double edge safety razor from Baxter of California. It comes with a pack of starter blades and an instructional card to help you shave like a pro. Packaged in a matte black box, it makes for the perfect gift.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase a Baxter of California Shave Tonic and receive a complimentary Baxter of California Trial Size Shave Duo!



~ Best Treatments ~



Recipe for Men Under Eye Gel

This lightweight eye gel utilizes caffeine to help reduce puffiness and the appearance of dark circles, while black tea helps to increase softness, elasticity and reduce lines caused by dryness. Algae, cucumber and aloe vera help soothe and hydrate the delicate skin around the eyes, fighting puffiness and the development of wrinkles.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase the Recipe for Men Under Eye Gel and receive a complimentary Recipe for Men deluxe sample pack!





Raw Materials Skin Grit

A fine grained natural scrub gentle enough for the face, tough enough for the body. Crushed walnut shells and jojoba beads unclog pores, remove dead skin and soften fresh skin. Perfect before shaving or 2-3 times a week. 98% natural ingredients.




This highly effective acne treatment synthesizes salicylic acid with 10% active sulfur to dry and medicate acne. Balanced with organic camphor to help fight impurities, the formula incorporates zinc oxide to aid and help prevent scarring. Intended to be used for occasional adult acne.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase the Malin+Goetz Acne Treatment Nighttime and receive a complimentary 1 oz Malin+Goetz Vitamin E Shaving Cream!




This rich, creamy formulation - a unique combination of naturally derived UV protective mineral derived sunscreens and skin moisturizing humectants- provides maximum strength protection but is gentle enough for the most sensitive complexions.Uses safe, naturally derived mineral sunscreens Titanium Dioxide and Zinc Oxide to provide broad spectrum SPF 50 protection.




A gel formula that actively hydrates the skin. Helps reduce the appearance of fine surface lines. Potent antioxidants protect from oxidative stress & damage.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase an Urth Skin Solutions for Men HydraTherapy and receive a complimentary Urth Skin Solutions for Men Dry Hand Rescue! 




Urth Skin Solutions for Men Botanical Resurfacing Mask

A purifying treatment that renews the complexion, skin tone and increases skin firmness. Mineral enriched clays and pure plant ingredients gently exfoliate and detoxify the skin’s surface to shrink pores as well as fight acne-prone and oily skin. For congested, combination and mature skin.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase an Urth Skin Solutions for Men Botanical Resurfacing Mask and receive a complimentary travel size Urth Skin Solutions for Men Face Scrub!




A unique no shine lip balm that locks in moisture allowing active ingredients to protect and prevent dryness. Provides a physical block to wind and other extreme conditions. Peppermint oil provides natural cooling and soothing. Avocado oil and shea butter provide moisture.



~ Best Haircare & Styling ~


Keep your hair and your cool. Protect yourself with Fuzzy Logic, an advanced peppermint shampoo formula fortified with DHT blocking agents, fighting hair loss at its roots. Fuzzy Logic will protect your magnificent mane of hair, allowing you to focus more on getting looks for the right reasons.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase a full size Billy Jealousy Fuzzy Logic Strengthening Shampoo and receive a complimentary travel size Billy Jealousy Cashmere Coat Conditioner!




A natural ingredient conditioner that's perfect for hair that needs some extra moisture and protection from damage and split ends. Intensively moisturizes and nourishes hair, while protecting from breakage. Protects against the damaging effects of the environment and styling products. Ideal for curly, very dry, dehydrated or damaged hair.




A superior quality, medium weight, water based pomade that gives your hair high gloss with a very strong hold. Great for holding tall pomps, distressed mess or the clean cut business man look. This pomade is water based, so it washes out easily.




A highly pliable, light styling creme for massive volume. A no look creme gives light to medium hold with natural shine.



~ Best Hand and Body ~


This body scrub uses Jojoba Esters to scrub away dead skin cells. Natural lime, lemon and orange fruit extracts soften and moisturize skin. Aloe vera soothes and softens, leaving skin clean, polished and renewed.

Best In Shop Offer: Purchase a full size Billy Jealousy Salad Days Body Scrub and receive a complimentary travel size Billy Jealousy Adrenaline Junkie Energizing Scrub!




Buckler's Moisture Rich Soap is a natural, gently exfoliating bar soap that cleanses skin while restoring hydration and nutrients. Fine grains of vanilla bean provide extra gentle exfoliation. Shea butter leaves skin with long lasting, deep hydration. Honey is a natural anti microbial that also helps skin retain nutrients and moisture. Vitamin-rich almond oil gives skin a healthy, youthful glow.




A heavy-duty, non-oily, all climate formula that provides deep hydration, repairing chapped, irritated skin and guarding it from the effects of the elements.





Speick Natural Deo Stick

Great for sensitive skin. Effective but gentle. Natural ingredients. Free of aluminum salts and mineral oil.